Buffalo Trace produces some of the most loved bourbons in America—and two bottles stand above the rest: Buffalo Trace and Eagle Rare 10 Year.
But which one should you buy in 2025?
This comparison covers taste, price, availability, aging, and value so you can choose the best bottle for your money.
👉 Ready to buy? Check availability for Eagle Rare 10 Year Bourbon
Overview: Buffalo Trace vs Eagle Rare 10
Both bourbons come from the same distillery—but they appeal to different drinkers.
Buffalo Trace
•No age statement (approx. 7–9 years)
•More widely available
•Often cheaper ($25–$35)
•Sweeter and more beginner-friendly
Eagle Rare 10 Year
•Aged full 10 years
•Small batch
•Limited allocations
•More oak depth and complexity
•Higher collectible interest
Flavor Comparison
Buffalo Trace Flavor Notes
Caramel • Brown sugar • Cinnamon • Vanilla
Eagle Rare 10 Flavor Notes
Vanilla • Oak • Honey • Dried fruit • Almond
Winner: Eagle Rare (more complexity due to age)
Price Comparison
•Buffalo Trace MSRP: $25–$35
•Eagle Rare MSRP: $35–$45
•Market Price Advantage: Buffalo Trace is easier to find at normal pricing.
•Collector Value: Eagle Rare wins.
Availability
Buffalo Trace is easier to find in most states.
Eagle Rare is allocated, meaning only some stores receive limited stock each month.
👉 Want to skip the hunt? Check the product page: Eagle Rare 10 Year Bourbon
Which Is Better for Beginners?
•If you’re new to bourbon → Buffalo Trace
•If you enjoy aged, richer bourbon → Eagle Rare 10
Which Bourbon Holds Value Better?
Eagle Rare wins here because age-stated Buffalo Trace products often appreciate in demand.
Verdict: Which Should You Buy?
If you want:
✔ Smooth, easy-drinking, affordable → choose Buffalo Trace
✔ Rich flavor, higher age, and collectible value → choose Eagle Rare 10 Year
Conclusion
Both bourbons deliver excellent value for 2025. But if you want deeper flavor, better aging, and something special on your shelf, Eagle Rare 10 Year is the clear winner.